Check out the Latest Articles:
Comments Off on The Best Star Wars Nonrequired Reading of 2015

You’ve seen Star Wars (very possibly more than once) and you want to join in the critical conversation, or at least see what people are going on about. Here’s a list of the best writing on the web about the new Star Wars film, The Force Awakens.

What follows is a list of the best articles I’ve read about the new Star Wars film, please suggest more in the comments and I may edit in additions if people point them out. This isn’t everything I’ve read, but you can find that list online too. All links here are from a central site where I’ve archived the pieces, but they will forward you to the original piece.

From here on out, there will be spoilers.


Our Star Wars Holiday Special – The New Inquiry

The New Inquiry’s Aaron Bady takes the inclination to hyper-analyze Star Wars and the very idea of its originality and puts both under the microscope. That makes it the best candidate for perspective to start with before you dive deep into the critics.

Rey is not a role model for little girls (major spoilers ahead) Mike Adamick

Mike Adamick takes on and breaks down what makes Rey different from the endless boy heroes, a trend significantly boosted by the original Star Wars series. This unmissable piece discusses the significant positive impact of Rey as the hero of the new film.

The “Star Wars” fandom menace: The glaring emotional blind spots that power “The Force Awakens” –

Lili Loofbourow at Salon takes on the problems of scale implicit in the plot of The Force Awakens. If you’re at all interested in the ethics and impact of Star Wars on the modern media mind, Loofbourow breaks down the tragedy of Star Wars biggest flaw, how The Force Awakens gets away with it and what it means.

How Rey and ‘The Force Awakens’ could change ‘Star Wars’ forever – The Washington Post

What to do when you’re not the hero any more

Both The Washington Post’s Alyssa Rosenberg and Laurie Penny for the New Statesman take on how Rey offers a direct challenge to the traditional Hero’s Journey narrative archetype, with Penny sketching it out on the larger cultural stage and Rosenberg diving deep into the mechanics of change in The Force Awakens.

Star Wars Merch’s Sexism Problem: #WheresRey Highlights Dearth in Female Toys – The Daily Beast

Jen Yamato documents the continuing trends in franchising and how they’ve led up to the dearth of Rey toys on the shelves. Throughout, Yamato tracks the rise and possible success of the #WheresRey social media campaign and takes care to illustrate why having more Rey action figures for sale is important.

Dear “Star Wars” fans: I’m super sorry I ruined the whole thing for everybody –

Andrew O’Hehir, also of Salon, challenges the idea that any film franchise–much less one as large as Star Wars–requires its fans to jump to its defense.

Every person you follow or block, every app you use, you’re making a trade-off, the hope that this new stream of information will give you exactly what you need in exchange for closing yourself off a little more from the rest of the world.

There have been a lot of things written about “the filter bubble” in the last few years. The idea is that the people we follow, the posts matching what an algorithm thinks you’ll like, and the mobile apps that we use create a sort of illusion of information. We think it’s the whole story, but we’re getting a version of reality that we, or some program, think we want.

There are a lot of people out there who are trying to build the best bubble for you. Some may do it just by being the people you like to follow on Twitter, others (like Yahoo’s News Digest) build a little miniature internet for you, where you read what they think is important and can only use their tools to do so. There are some who are trying to figure out how to break out of the bubble, but not many. The problem is, even given the most open and free web possible, we tend to build the bubbles around ourselves. We all have our own interests and we search out the content on the internet that relates to those interests. Sometimes we don’t even know that there is something else cool out there to ask for.

The usual solution is to follow people or publications that we trust. We follow them and hope that they can do a better job of finding the things we want to read, watch and listen to than we can. Sometimes we hope that algorithms, like Facebook’s, will be able to help.

I’m not saying any of this filtering is necessarily bad. It can, but doesn’t have to, be. I do think it is worth thinking about though, as consciously and as continually as we can. I try hard to build bubbles that deform at various walls, stretching out to weird topics, people and ideas that I wouldn’t normally be exposed to, but even that is hard.

To help me think about all this (and perhaps to help you) I’ve been building sites and tools to help me look at my own information consumption and show it to others. The latest is a little something I call Dropcat, it stands for Drop Categories. I’m opening the source code today and letting anyone check out the alpha version. It has been a fun coding challenge. I’ve picked up a bunch of new ideas and skills putting it together the last few weeks; I’d never really used AngularJS before.

What’s the idea behind Dropcat? Well, it hooks into, a site where I broadcast and archive everything I read on the web. Dropcat is an experiment: how can I build a tool for others that will shrink the filter bubble to as small as it can get? The site displays the last few stories in any category that comes off You can select a broad category, or a narrower topic underneath it. Instead of going out to the wider web, you can theoretically just use this single page. If you find a topic you like, you can leave it open, it will automatically refresh itself with the latest stories I aggregate, as soon as they come in.

If you select a category and a child category, I figure that this is the theoretical smallest bubble for filtering the wider web. As a tool, Dropcat could be more useful and I may make it so in the future. Lots more data can be made available about even the posts I have pulled in here, or I could have it automatically pull in a wider set of posts from other sites. There are lots of things it can potentially be, but right now it is just this. I sort of like it that way. Hopefully it is a useful tool in making us all think about how closed off we can make ourselves to the rest of the internet and all the information that is out there.


This isn’t the first thing I’ve done that plays with this idea of building a myopic web.

Going to work at

Big news! Starting next week I’ll be working with as a Full Stack Developer. Salon has always been a website to watch and they are doing great things working with journalism, the mobile web and WordPress. When I interviewed with them, it was clear that they’ve also got plenty of awesome projects still to come. I’m […]

If you came to this post from my Facebook you’ve been participating in a little not-so-scientific experiment on my behalf. For most of the month of January almost all of my Facebook shares have passed through a new site I set up with WordPress and PressForward. On I archive a copy of everything I’ve read […]

My 12 rules for talking with others on the internet

The hardest part of doing better on the internet (at least for me, and in my experience for many others) is following these rules. I don’t always get there, but I’m always trying.

Response Stack: build stories out of reader comments.

I’m releasing a new WordPress plugin today that allows you to use shortcodes to embed comments and comment threads into the body of stories. It’s called Response Stack. The goal is to build stories out of comments and help both the original story and the discussion around it live on. You can see the first […]